Do you wish to view this page in English? Change language

Chief Financial Officer

Chief Financial Officer (CFO)

Property & Casualty Insurance | Greater Tampa Bay Area | On-Site

The Opportunity

Our firm has been retained by a well-established and growing Property & Casualty insurance organization to identify a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to join its executive leadership team.

The organization specializes in Workers’ Compensation insurance and has experienced significant growth. With continued geographic expansion, product development, and investment in its operating capabilities, the business is looking to bring on a commercially minded financial executive who can help guide its next phase of growth.

Reporting directly to the CEO, the CFO will serve as a key strategic advisor to executive leadership and the Board of Directors. This individual will oversee Finance, Accounting, Actuarial, Compliance, and Data & Analytics, with responsibility for strengthening financial performance, optimizing capital strategy, improving operational effectiveness, and driving long-term enterprise value.

This is a broad executive leadership position requiring more than traditional financial oversight. The successful candidate will bring a strong understanding of the P&C insurance business and how underwriting, pricing, claims, reserving, reinsurance, and distribution ultimately impact financial performance and profitability.

Key Responsibilities

  • Develop and execute the organization’s long-term financial strategy in partnership with the CEO and executive leadership team.

  • Translate business objectives into comprehensive financial plans, budgets, forecasts, capital requirements, and measurable performance targets.

  • Lead the Finance, Accounting, Actuarial, Compliance, and Data & Analytics functions, establishing strong leadership, accountability, and operational discipline.

  • Oversee financial reporting and ensure accuracy, transparency, and compliance with GAAP, statutory accounting, regulatory, and governance requirements.

  • Direct financial planning, budgeting, forecasting, and long-range planning processes, ensuring alignment between business strategy and financial performance.

  • Provide executive oversight of actuarial functions, including reserving, pricing support, loss projections, financial modeling, and forecasting.

  • Partner closely with underwriting, claims, product, operations, and risk leadership to evaluate insurance performance, profitability, pricing, and emerging trends.

  • Monitor key insurance performance indicators, including premium growth, loss and expense ratios, combined ratio, reserve development, and profitability by product and business segment.

  • Oversee capital, liquidity, investment, reinsurance, and financial risk strategies to support the organization’s financial strength and growth objectives.

  • Evaluate new business opportunities, strategic partnerships, acquisitions, new products, and geographic expansion through financial modeling, valuation, due diligence, and risk assessment.

  • Identify opportunities to improve profitability, operating efficiency, productivity, margins, and return on investment.

  • Drive financial and operational transformation through process improvements, automation, technology, data analytics, and artificial intelligence.

  • Establish and maintain strong financial controls, policies, compliance practices, and governance frameworks.

  • Build, develop, and retain high-performing teams across Finance, Accounting, Actuarial, Compliance, and Data & Analytics.

  • Represent the organization with external auditors, regulators, financial institutions, and other key stakeholders.

Candidate Profile

The organization is seeking an experienced insurance finance executive with the commercial acumen, technical expertise, and leadership capabilities to influence business strategy and drive financial results.

Required Qualifications & Experience

  • Bachelor’s degree in Finance, Accounting, Economics, Actuarial Science, Business Administration, or a related field.

  • 10+ years of progressive experience in finance, accounting, actuarial, or insurance-related leadership positions.

  • Direct experience within an insurance carrier in a senior financial leadership capacity is required.

  • Demonstrated success improving profitability, forecasting accuracy, capital efficiency, financial transparency, or overall enterprise value.

  • Experience leading significant financial or operational transformation initiatives, including process improvements, technology implementation, and organizational development.

  • Strong understanding of insurance financial performance, including underwriting results, reserving, pricing, claims, reinsurance, and capital management.

Preferred Qualifications

  • Property & Casualty insurance experience, particularly within Workers’ Compensation, Commercial Lines, or similarly regulated insurance environments.

  • Experience within an MGA (Managing General Agency) environment, including underwriting, delegated authority, pricing, profitability, and carrier/MGA relationships.

  • Direct leadership or oversight of an Actuarial function.

  • Experience presenting financial, actuarial, and strategic matters to a Board of Directors and executive leadership team.

  • Background in acquisitions, divestitures, strategic partnerships, debt and capital arrangements, economic capital, and stress testing.